要件审判九步法
下载地址
https://www.zhengdianxue.com/wp-content/uploads/skills/org-kdl8pmoi--yaojian-shenpan-jiubufa.zip将提示词发送给你的 AI 安装该 skills
请根据 https://skillhub.cn/install/skillhub.md,安装 @org-kdl8pmoi/yaojian-shenpan-jiubufa。面向民商事案件的九步分析工作流,可梳理诉请、抗辩、要件、争点与证据。方法参考邹碧华《要件审判九步法》(法律出版社,2010 年),技能操作说明独立编写。
阅读全文 (展开查看完整说明)
概述
触发与不触发
自动调用:用户要求按本书九步法分析民商事案件,或明确希望用书中的某一步处理具体问题。一般民商事案件分析、通用法律概念和法条查询按其原任务处理。不适用:
- 不据 2010 年书中法条直接判断现行案件的法律效力
- 不替代法官或当事人的程序决定
核心原则(常驻速览,概览类问题读到这里即可回答)
- 以权利请求为起点
- 请求权和抗辩基础分别核定
- 规范要件与事实主张逐项对应
- 证明围绕争点组织
- 事实认定之后逐项归入
- 文书与审理过程保持一致
能力路由(先读本表,按意图加载 1 张能力卡)
| 用户意图 | 先读 | 补读/备注 |
|---|---|---|
| 按九步审理案件 | references/capabilities/nine-step-route.md | references/capabilities/fix-claim.md、references/capabilities/check-judgment-consistency.md |
| 澄清并固定诉请 | references/capabilities/fix-claim.md | references/capabilities/find-claim-basis.md、references/capabilities/choose-competing-claim.md |
| 寻找请求权基础 | references/capabilities/find-claim-basis.md | references/capabilities/choose-competing-claim.md、references/capabilities/map-legal-elements.md |
| 比较竞合请求 | references/capabilities/choose-competing-claim.md | references/capabilities/fix-claim.md、references/capabilities/find-claim-basis.md |
| 区分抗辩与否认 | references/capabilities/find-defense-basis.md | references/capabilities/map-legal-elements.md、references/capabilities/apply-elements.md |
| 拆解法律构成要件 | references/capabilities/map-legal-elements.md | references/capabilities/check-pleadings.md、references/capabilities/organize-issues.md |
| 核对诉讼主张 | references/capabilities/check-pleadings.md | references/capabilities/organize-issues.md |
| 整理法律与事实争点 | references/capabilities/organize-issues.md | references/capabilities/plan-proof.md |
| 围绕争点安排证明 | references/capabilities/plan-proof.md | references/capabilities/find-facts.md |
| 认定要件事实 | references/capabilities/find-facts.md | references/capabilities/apply-elements.md |
| 逐项要件归入 | references/capabilities/apply-elements.md | references/capabilities/stop-irrelevant-proof.md、references/capabilities/check-judgment-consistency.md |
| 停止无关调查 | references/capabilities/stop-irrelevant-proof.md | references/capabilities/apply-elements.md |
| 复核裁判文书 | references/capabilities/check-judgment-consistency.md | references/capabilities/nine-step-route.md、references/capabilities/apply-elements.md |
| 新事实出现后重选规范 | references/capabilities/iterate-facts-and-rules.md | references/capabilities/find-claim-basis.md、references/capabilities/map-legal-elements.md |
显式调用后的资料查询:
- 书名/作者/章节/整书概览 → references/overview.md
- 术语解释 → references/glossary.md
- 决策规则速查(不需要原文依据时) → references/cheatsheet.md
- 完整意图与关键词索引(本表未覆盖的意图先查这里) → references/capability-index.md
加载规则
- 每次任务先读本文件,再按路由表加载 1 张能力卡;任务明确跨域时最多加载 2 张。
- 仅查询书目或全书概览时,显式调用后读取 references/overview.md,无需加载能力卡。
- 路由表与 capability-index.md 都无法命中的意图,明确告知超出本书范围,不要硬套。
边界与判停
- 缺少关键案情、证据或适用时点的有效法律规范时停止实体结论